-Photoroom.png)
Is Debt Relief a Good Idea? Here’s When It Helps — and When It Can Hurt
QUICK ANSWER
Is debt relief a good idea? The truth is, it depends on your situation. Debt relief can help you reduce what you owe and avoid bankruptcy — but it can also impact your credit and come with added costs. Carefully weighing the pros and cons can help you determine if debt relief is the right choice for your financial situation.
by Horizon Debt Relief | July 15, 2025 | Debt Solutions
Key Takeaways
Debt relief is not a one-size-fits-all solution. It can help reduce unsecured debt, but it comes with fees, credit score impact, and potential tax obligations.
Best for serious financial hardship. Programs are most useful for people with high unsecured debt who are behind on payments and have limited other options.
Not suitable for secured debts. Mortgages, car loans, and other collateral-backed loans are not eligible for settlement.
The right path depends on your budget, debt load, and long-term goals — but informed action is always the first step toward financial freedom.
Debt Relief: When It’s (and Isn’t) the Right Choice to Get Out of Debt
Feeling overwhelmed by debt is more common than you might think. Millions of people in the U.S. struggle to keep up with credit card payments, personal loans, or other unsecured debts. When monthly bills start piling up, a debt relief company may step in to negotiate with your lenders and help reduce what you owe.This process, also called debt settlement, aims to help you pay less than your total balance. Done correctly, it can help you regain control of your finances and even avoid bankruptcy.
However, debt relief is not a guaranteed fix. It doesn’t apply to loans backed by collateral, such as a mortgage or car loan. Even if a settlement is successful, your credit score will likely take a hit, and fees can reach up to 25% of your enrolled debt.
Still, for people facing overwhelming debt, it might be an option worth considering. Here’s a clear, step-by-step guide to help you decide whether debt relief might be the right choice for your situation.
How Debt Relief Works
Debt relief companies work on your behalf to negotiate lower balances with your creditors — usually credit card issuers, lenders, or collection agencies.
Here’s how the process typically unfolds:
1. Enrollment: You sign up with a debt relief company and list the debts you want to include. Debt relief programs focus primarily on unsecured debts — such as credit cards, personal loans, or medical bills — that don’t have collateral. Most programs require at least $7,500 in unsecured debt to qualify.
2. Payment Suspension: During this time, the company usually advises you to pause payments to your creditors. Instead of paying them directly, you deposit money into a dedicated account. While this helps you build funds for negotiation, it also causes late fees and can temporarily lower your credit score.
3. Negotiation Phase: Once enough funds are available, the company contacts your creditors to negotiate a settlement — often 40%–60% of your original balance. Creditors are not required to accept, but many will if they believe full repayment is unlikely.
4. Settlement and Payment: If a deal is reached, your account funds are used to pay the negotiated balance and the remaining balance is forgiven.
Costs and Fees
Debt relief programs are not free, but legitimate companies are transparent about costs.
Service Fees: Most companies charge a percentage of the total debt you enroll — typically 14% to 25%. For example, if you enroll $20,000, you might owe between $2,800 and $5,000 in service fees. Always remember that reputable companies only charge their main fees after they’ve successfully settled a debt — never upfront.
Account Maintenance Fees: Many programs use a third-party account to hold your funds until settlements are reached. These accounts can come with small setup fees ($8–$10) and monthly maintenance charges ($9–$10).
Minimum Debt Requirements: To qualify, you typically need at least $7,500 in unsecured debt. Smaller balances usually don't justify the cost.
Impact on Credit and Taxes
It’s important to understand the potential effects before enrolling:
Credit Score: Because you stop paying creditors during the negotiation phase, your credit score will drop — often significantly. Late payments and charge-offs can stay on your credit report for up to seven years. That said, once your debts are resolved and balances show as “settled,” rebuilding your credit is possible with consistent payments and responsible credit use.
Tax Implications: Forgiven debt over $600 is considered taxable income in the U.S. For instance, if $10,000 of your debt is forgiven, that $10,000 could count as income on your next tax return. A quick talk with a tax professional can help you prepare for that.
When Debt Relief Might Not Be the Right Choice
Debt relief isn’t suitable for everyone. It may not be ideal if:
1. Your Debts Are Still Manageable: If you can keep up with payments, options like consolidation or negotiating directly with creditors can be safer and less costly.
2. You Have Secured Debts: Debt relief doesn’t cover loans tied to collateral — like mortgages or car loans.
Missing payments could put your property at risk.
3. You Need to Protect Your Credit Score: Since you’ll be pausing payments for a while, your credit will take a hit.
If you’re planning to buy a home, refinance, or apply for new credit soon, it’s probably best to wait.
4. You Want to Avoid Tax Surprises
Forgiven debt counts as taxable income. A large settlement could increase your annual tax bill or affect your eligibility for certain tax credits. It’s not a deal breaker for many, but it’s something to plan for.
When Debt Relief Could Be the Right Choice
Despite the downsides, there are times when debt relief truly helps people turn their financial lives around. It might be worth considering if:
-
You owe $10,000 or more in unsecured debt;
-
You’re already behind and struggling to catch up;
-
You’ve run out of options for refinancing or consolidation;
-
You’re willing to accept a temporary credit score drop for long-term debt relief.
For many, it’s a way to avoid bankruptcy, reduce what’s owed, and finally start over with a clean slate.
A Closer Look at the Debt Settlement Process
Debt settlement differs from other forms of relief because it focuses on negotiating lump-sum settlements rather than adjusting repayment terms. The goal of debt settlement is to reach a point where your creditors agree to accept less than the full balance — often around 40% to 60% of what you owe.
Not every creditor will say yes, but many prefer getting something rather than nothing. During this time, some debts might go to collections, and you may receive calls, letters, or legal notices. A reputable company will help manage those communications and guide you through each step.
Completing the program usually takes two to four years, depending on your budget. Dropping out early, however, can undo progress and leave you responsible for the full debt plus accrued interest.
After the Program: Rebuilding Credit and Confidence
When your debts are finally settled, it can feel like a huge weight lifted off your shoulders.
the next step is rebuilding your credit and confidence:
-
Pay remaining accounts on time and maintain good payment habits;
-
Use credit carefully — small, manageable purchases paid off monthly help restore your score;
-
Check your credit reports for accuracy and dispute any errors.
With consistent effort, many people see their credit and financial stability improve significantly within a few years.
Weighing the Pros and Cons
Potential Benefits
Possible Drawbacks
Can significantly reduce what you owe
Consolidates multiple debts into one plan
Provides relief from collection calls
Helps avoid bankruptcy
Clear timeline to becoming debt-free
Emotional relief — a fresh start
Temporary drop in credit score
Program fees can be high
Creditors aren’t required to settle
Forgiven debt is taxable
Requires commitment and patience
Risk of legal action during negotiations
Bottom Line
Debt relief can be a smart move for some, but it’s not the perfect solution for everyone. It tends to work best when your debts are high, unsecured, and have become too difficult to manage — and when other options, like refinancing or consolidation, are no longer realistic.
Before enrolling, make sure you understand what comes with it: there are program fees, your credit may take a hit, and forgiven debt can be taxable. Still, for many people, the chance to finally get out from under overwhelming balances is worth those trade-offs.
Ask yourself a few key questions before moving forward:
-
Are my debts truly unmanageable?
-
Will my creditors likely negotiate?
-
Can I commit to making steady deposits each month?
-
Am I prepared for a short-term drop in my credit score?
If the answer to most of these is yes, debt relief could be the first real step toward getting your finances — and peace of mind — back on track.
Next Step: Evaluate Your Debt Situation
If you’re unsure whether debt relief is the right move for you, you don’t have to figure it out alone.
A professional debt evaluation can help you understand your full financial picture and explore every option.
A thorough assessment will show you exactly how much you owe, what your options are, and which approach makes the most sense for your goals. It’s a simple way to get clarity before making any big decisions.
Quickly discover:
If you qualify for a personalized debt relief program
What your repayment options look like, including potential costs and timelines
How the process works and what to expect next
It's fast, simple & no-obligation
*In Association with Curadebt
